This week I spoke to a group of young legal practitioners here in New Zealand. I aimed low and went back to source. I suspect I got more of a kick out of it than anyone at the session.

So, mediators, look away. There is nothing new here.

But users, occasional or repeat, I hope these three essential elements peek an interest in the rich vein of mediation theory that pulses through every mediation – high stakes mega technology case or barking dog dispute.

1. Let’s start at the beginning with the Five Sources Of ALL Conflict*

  • Data conflict caused by misinformation/lack of information, poor communication
  • Interest conflict caused by perceived or actual competition over substantive content (land, money etc)
  • Structural conflict caused by unequal control/ownership
  • Value conflict caused by different criteria for evaluating ideas etc, different ways of life
  • Relationship conflicts caused by strong emotions, stereotypes, poor communication

Capture3

2. Then there is the Satisfaction Triangle that reminds us that there are three elements to real, lasting closure – procedural (“we were listened to/it was transparent/it had a coherent structure”) emotional  (“my sense of wrong was acknowledged/legitimated”) substantive (“the  outcome was in the range of feasible results”) and if each of the three sides of the triangle are addressed in some way in the mediation process, resolution is more likely.**

Capture

3. Finally there is the Pareto Frontier –  sometimes called win/win but better described as ‘I can live with that/I can live with that’ or ‘the highest level of benefit for either party’. This reminds us that while some disputes are zero-sum games and will resolve themselves somewhere on the compromise line, others are multifaceted and can only be resolved by moving off positions and off compromise (more for me means less for you) and onto interests.

For more, Google ‘Pareto Frontier’ or ‘negotiation interests and positions’.  Better still read about the kids who both wanted the same orange…

Capture2

 * Thanks to Chris Moore’s The Mediation Process, a book that should grace every mediator’s bookshelf
** Thanks to John Wade, Bond University


________________________

To make sure you do not miss out on regular updates from the Kluwer Mediation Blog, please subscribe here.


Kluwer Arbitration

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *